Look, I think most of us would agree that we like the ‘concept’, and myself in particular loved the emphasis on trying to recreate the atmosphere of the original (and still the greatest) movie.
For the most part people aren’t complaining about the type of game it is - they’re quite rightly complaining about the increasingly buggy state of it, which has got to the point where a major game mechanic (Pred’s melee) results in game crashes for a large proportion of the players. That ‘beautiful arsenal’ of the Pred is rendered pretty useless when you can only use a couple of weapons because all the others freeze the Pred solid when you try to use them. Players want to actually use them as opposed to just gaze admiringly at them in the weapons loadout screens.
So yes, “this game IS broken” and it’s currently in one of the worst states it’s been, with no concrete word on when a hotfix is due, so you shouldn’t be surprised that not many here are professing love for it at the moment.
…and I’m not even going to bother going into the hot mess which is the current balance.