So many people trash on it yet I’ve never heard a good reason for why it’s bad.
The most common two is it punishes players for improving and sets you up against opponents who are too good
A. Having players face similarly skilled opponents isn’t a punishment it’s called balancing.
B. What do you think no SBMM does? Sets you up against better opponents. Hell I had some one tell me that facing better opponents outside of our skill ranges is a good thing, in support of no SBMM. SBMM helps the latter problem, not make it.
An argument I heard once was that SBMM gets in the way of flow but that’s not true. It just isn’t. Any reason why it would, no SBMM is worse.
That’s the problem here, it’s not how the game is at base with SBMM, it’s SBMM versus no SBMM. And every problem is worse without it.
Unless your the top 10% in case your just constantly trashing on people and that’s not balanced.