No he can’t. He directed a movie. He didint write it. George Lucas wrote Star Wars. So he got to decide what’s happening in the universe. I can’t just say, “well I prefer this!” And change it lol that’s not how that works.
Proof this game, and extended universe. Are not cannon.
tells an opinion
that’s not an opinion
Okay, bruv.
Once again, have you seen the movie?
Yes he can, you don’t, he said it but what I want to say is that it does not matter, you decide what you like and what you don’t
Ah, yes, only the corporate managers that work for a capitalist entity that is only interested in profit can decide what’s canon and not.
Not like this is all completely made up and you are the only person who can decide what’s canon and what’s not.
I literally said I could be wrong. Get your salt ass outa here. But again. It’s gonna be total dog shit. Please, you tell me what will make this different than the last 8 installments of films like this
Not corporate managers you shit head. The person who wrote the story. You are such a cuck on here lol always trying to spin peoples words. If I meant corporate managers I’d have said corporate managers. The woman who wrote Harry Potter, decides what’s Cannon in Harry Potter. Not the guy who directed one of the movies. Make sense dumb dumb
Whoever writes a story, decides what’s cannon and what’s not cannon, to there story. That’s my entire point. Some video game company can’t come along and change the story, was my entire point here.
Honestly this is all hype mongering. This was peddled from producers, not actual actors or director. I’ll wait till I see it.
No, she doesn’t. It’s doesn’t matter what Rowling says. As long as you just remember that any piece of fiction the second it is available to public becomes part of popular culture. And we as public can decide what we want or don’t want to treat as canon.
If you don’t like the new movie - and it can be dogshit - you can just ignore it. Because the executives or writers don’t have any power over you and your relationship with the property.
Again. Everyone is down my throat right now. MY ENTIRE POINT. Is that the films are what hold the “canon”. I obviously want the movie to be good. I want the movie to be successful. I think the concept, sounds awesome! But so did the concept for the predator when we first heard leaks. And alien covenant. And the last 4 terminators. I just have little faith they will pull off anything good. But I’d LOVE to be wrong
So I can just take her intellectual work and contort it to my choosing? It’s now CONFIRMED you literally have 0 desire to come to any sort of mutual understanding. You’re just one of those people who’s so thirsty to be right
1 Like
People have literally killed themselves (like actually) who have made properties, then had them raped by bigger corporations over profits.
Yes, you can.
Why are you treating her work like some sort of gospel? If you wanna take core elements and disregard some elements - do it.
You’re literally in a mind cage created by the “IP laws” bullshit.
That’s why I say that we should stop giving power to big corporations by playing into their “this is canon and this is not” narratives.
You are literally saying nothing at this point . “No corporations can’t decide the canon” “no the author doesn’t get to decide the canon, whoever makes the next installment can just change whatever” you are literally spouting incoherent nonsense that completely contradicts what you’d just said.
So we’ll just have to agree to disagree cause you’re on your “I need to be right😩” deal right now and conversations with people like that go no where
If you just pick a stance, I can’t say you’re wrong. It’s subjective. But if you’re going to go back and forth depending on what helps your side at that actual moment then what are we even doing here.
Hope the new movie proves me wrong though maybe it will be good 👍🏼
Just agree to disagree. I don’t like seeing Melons insult each other like that over nothing.
Unless you’re insulting @Fire
Fuck that guy.
3 Likes
No, it’s really simple. No one, but you can decide what’s canon and what’s not. Because you interpret a piece of media. Author or a corporation can’t decide for you what’s canon and what’s not. Especially since they don’t have any authority over you like, say, any give church.
It’s a very simple concept, tbf.
My position is literally extremely straightforward and simple.
You and only you can decide how to interpret media. And instead you choose to listen to people with “authority” who tell you how to a piece of media.
Hahahah yeah fuck fire. But no I’m just over this particular person trying to alway tell you you’re wrong, and ACTIVELY switching sides mid argument to help there point lol gets old ya know