Didint read this. Your points always contradict one another so why bother. But I’ll finish again by saying in my opinion, the person who creates a work of fiction is the one who decides what’s canon to there story, because it’s… there story. Lol duh.
It’s your story and if someone else wants to have there own story, write your own story.
Proof this game, and extended universe. Are not cannon.
If you could point to a contradiction in my point I’d be very grateful.
Well ridley Scott has screwed up everything, personally I like predator and if I want alien I go to avp, I do not care if it is canonical or not
I said these companies don’t have the right to alter someone’s story, or intellectual property. You said yea they do. Then I said I think the person who writes a story is the one who has the right to decide what happens in there own story (cause duh.) you said no they don’t.
Then you went on to say these big corporations should not be allowed to decide what’s canon and not canon.
Your entire starting point in this thread was that these big corporations should not be allowed to decide the canon, then when I said it should be up to the author you said no it should not. So BY YOUR LOGIC. Just no one is allowed to tell the narrative. And having a continuity is just not a thing.
Which is just nonsense because all the most successful stories ever told hold great continuity and are praised for doing so
Oh I don’t care either! You’re missing my point. I love AVP. My entire point is that Ridley Scott doesn’t decide the canon and neither does predator Hunting grounds.
A movie doesn’t need to be “canon” to a storyline for me to enjoy it.
See, I ragged on Scott and you went like “He made Alien bro”.
Nice to see you drank the Based Juice tho.
Refresh my memory
I mean he did make alien… not sure what you’re saying here hahaha he didint write alien. He made it
Not an issue. It’s pre-colonialization meaning it’s prior to 1560.
Samurai hunted in Feudal Japan which is where he picked up the theming. The Feudal era ends in 1868 meaning we have more than enough time for him to fuck around in Japan.
Alpha is too far back with relevant material being on the homeworld so he’s unaffected by any of this.
Viking works provided we only go off what’s in-game rather than the playstation blog or DLC description.
Valkyrie is the only one who doesn’t really work without fudging it a bit.
Otherwise Illfonic Predator’s are more recent developments and we have no reason to think they’re old. Elder, City Hunter, and Jungle Hunter are from the films so they’re accounted for. The only one we can’t speak of is Cleopatra since we don’t know if she was actually in Egypt or it’s a theme. AVP is also unaffected by this given the original relationship with humanity had a definitive end with nobody surviving the encounter and we don’t know when any of them came back. They do address it in The Predator so Predator 5 is the first encounter on technicality.
We were in a PSN Party, we were having a spat about Canon, and while I did say some dumb shit like “Scott made Covenant, I don’t have listen to what he says about canon”, you pretty much said the above. Of course, we both didn’t want to sperg out over it so we just dropped it.
1 Like
Well I’ll give you this one then cause that movie sucked balls lol covenant that is
I literally said the opposite.
No one. NO ONE. Not the author and especially not the corporation can tell you how to interpret media.
That’s my point. This whole “canon” argument is pointless, as we as the audience are the only people who can decide whether or not we wanna consider something worthy or, if you prefer, “canonical”.
That’s it. That’s my point.
Not how to interpret lol I said what’s canon. Interpretation of something has literally nothing to Do with canon. Wat
I really don’t care as long as the next movie takes part in the crusades says in irish accent
1 Like
In an attempt to broker peace or at the very least drop this I offer this:
Do with this what you will.
5 Likes
It worked. I raise the white flag
2 Likes
A god
1 Like
Ima rip off that eye patch and skull fuck you, you keep talking shit.
3 Likes